Top 9: Best Tiki Bars Florida Keys & Overseas Highway

Top 9: Best Tiki Bars Florida Keys & Overseas Highway

Welcome to the ultimate guide to tropical indulgence as we journey through the sun-kissed haven of the Florida Keys and the iconic Overseas Highway. Picture yourself swaying gently in a hammock, a gentle ocean breeze brushing against your skin, and the rhythmic sound of waves lapping at the shore. Now add to this scene the vibrant ambiance of a Tiki bar, where every sip of your cocktail transports you to a world of laid-back luxury and exotic charm.

In this enchanting stretch of paradise, Tiki bars aren’t just places to grab a drink; they’re experiences that encapsulate the essence of island life. From hidden gems tucked away in secluded coves to lively hotspots buzzing with energy, each Tiki bar along the Florida Keys and the Overseas Highway offers its own unique blend of flavors, decor, and atmosphere.

Join me as I embark on a journey to uncover the Top 9 Tiki Bars that promise to elevate your tropical escapade to new heights. Whether you’re a seasoned traveler or a first-time adventurer, prepare to immerse yourself in the spirit of aloha and embrace the carefree allure of island living. So sit back, relax, and let the rhythm of the tropics guide you on a quest for the perfect Tiki cocktail amidst the breathtaking backdrop of the Florida Keys and the Overseas Highway.

1. Sunset Grille & Raw Bar

Location: 7 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon, FL 33050

Sunset Grille & Raw Bar - Best tiki bars along the scenic Overseas Highway - Get ready for your road trip

Sunset Grille & Raw Bar stands as a luminous gem along the storied Overseas Highway that meanders through the picturesque Florida Keys. Nestled against the backdrop of the glistening Gulf of Mexico, this enchanting establishment has earned its reputation as one of the premier tiki bars in the region, captivating travelers and locals alike with its irresistible blend of laid-back ambiance, delectable cuisine, and breathtaking sunset vistas.

As one approaches the Sunset Grille, the inviting aroma of freshly grilled seafood and tropical cocktails wafts through the air, enticing passersby to stop and indulge in its offerings. Set amidst swaying palm trees and rustic wooden decks, the bar exudes a relaxed, island-inspired atmosphere that transports visitors to a state of blissful tranquility. Tiki torches flicker softly as patrons unwind in the shade of thatched-roof umbrellas, sipping on refreshing drinks and savoring the moment.

2. Gilbert’s Resort

Location: 107900 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Gilbert’s Resort - great tiki bar in Key Largo. Check my list of best tiki bars in the Florida Keys.

Located along the picturesque Overseas Highway in Key Largo, Florida, Gilbert’s Resort stands as a beacon of tropical bliss and island relaxation. Renowned as one of the finest tiki bars along the scenic stretch of the Overseas Highway, Gilbert’s Resort offers visitors an authentic slice of Caribbean-inspired paradise.

At the heart of Gilbert’s Resort is its legendary tiki bar, a thatched-roof oasis where tropical drinks flow freely and laughter fills the air. Bartenders skilled in the art of mixology craft an array of signature cocktails, from classic Mai Tais and Piña Coladas to inventive creations infused with fresh fruits and exotic flavors. Each sip is a tantalizing journey to paradise, perfectly complemented by the stunning waterfront views.

In the world of tiki bars along the Overseas Highway, Gilbert’s Resort stands tall as a beacon of tropical charm and hospitality. With its unbeatable location, delicious drinks, and laid-back vibe, it’s no wonder why Gilbert’s Resort is hailed as one of the best tiki bars in Key Largo – and a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a taste of paradise in the Florida Keys.

3. The Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar

Location: 96 Madeira Rd, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States

The Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar - another great bar for tourist and travelers.

Situated along the stunning shores of Islamorada in the Florida Keys, The Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar beckons travelers with its enchanting blend of tropical ambiance, delectable cuisine, and captivating waterfront views. Renowned as one of the premier tiki bars along the Overseas Highway, The Lorelei captures the essence of island living with its laid-back charm and vibrant atmosphere.

The focal point of The Lorelei experience is undoubtedly its acclaimed cabana bar, where skilled mixologists concoct an enticing array of tropical cocktails infused with the flavors of the Caribbean. From classic Mojitos and Rum Runners to inventive concoctions like the Lorelei Lava Flow, each sip is a tantalizing journey to paradise. As guests sip their drinks, they can unwind in the shade of swaying palm trees or gather around the bar to swap stories with fellow travelers, creating a convivial atmosphere that is quintessentially Keys.

But it’s not just the drinks and cuisine that make The Lorelei a standout destination along the Overseas Highway. The warm hospitality of the staff and the welcoming atmosphere make every visit feel like a cherished memory in the making. Whether you’re a seasoned traveler or a first-time visitor to the Keys, The Lorelei offers an authentic taste of island living that lingers long after the last cocktail has been sipped.

4. Sugarloaf Lodge Tiki Bar

Location: 17001 Overseas Hwy, Sugarloaf Shores, FL 33042

Sugarloaf Lodge Tiki Bar - the ultimate list of best tiki bars along the Overseas Highway.

Sugarloaf Lodge Tiki Bar is a charming and vibrant oasis nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, offering visitors a taste of paradise with its laid-back atmosphere, refreshing cocktails, and breathtaking waterfront views. Situated on Sugarloaf Key, this hidden gem beckons travelers and locals alike to unwind and indulge in the ultimate tropical escape.

Whether you’re seeking a romantic evening under the stars or a lively night out with friends, Sugarloaf Lodge Tiki Bar offers the perfect blend of relaxation, entertainment, and culinary delights. So grab a drink, kick back, and let the cares of the world melt away as you soak up the laid-back island vibes of this hidden paradise in the Florida Keys.

5. Kiki’s Sandbar & Grille

Location: 183 Barry Ave, Little Torch Key, FL 33042

Kiki's Sandbar & Grille - get ready for your next adventure with list of best tiki bars.

Kiki’s Sandbar & Grille is the epitome of a laid-back beachfront eatery, offering a relaxed atmosphere and stunning views of the shoreline. Nestled along the coast, it’s a popular haunt for locals and tourists alike, drawn in by its inviting ambiance and delicious fare.

The menu at Kiki’s Sandbar & Grille boasts a tempting array of pub grub and seafood favorites, each dish crafted with care and bursting with flavor. From crispy fish tacos and juicy burgers to fresh seafood platters piled high with shrimp, crab legs, and oysters, there’s something to satisfy every craving. The chefs pride themselves on using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, ensuring that each bite is fresh and delicious.

In addition to its mouthwatering food, Kiki’s also offers a well-stocked bar serving up an impressive selection of tropical cocktails, ice-cold beers, and refreshing mocktails. Sip on a fruity piña colada or indulge in a classic margarita as you soak up the laid-back vibes of the beachside setting.

6. Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill

Location: 85361 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036

Hog Heaven Sports Bar and Grill - tiki bars Overseas Highway best spots for drink and night fun.

For sports enthusiasts seeking a lively atmosphere, Hog Heaven is the ultimate destination. This waterfront sports bar boasts multiple flat-screen TVs, a full-service tiki bar, and a menu featuring all-American favorites like burgers, wings, and nachos. Whether you’re cheering on your favorite team or simply enjoying the ocean views, Hog Heaven is the perfect spot to unwind with friends.

Decorated with vibrant tropical motifs and illuminated by the warm glow of tiki torches, this bar transports visitors to an island paradise right in the heart of the bustling sports scene.

7. Burdines Waterfront

Location: 1200 Ocean View Ave, Marathon, FL 33050

Burdines Waterfront - Overseas Highway tiki bars

Burdines Waterfront is a popular restaurant located in Marathon, Florida, in the heart of the Florida Keys. Situated on the waterfront, it offers stunning views of the ocean and is known for its fresh seafood and casual atmosphere. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes including seafood platters, sandwiches, salads, and traditional Key West specialties. Many visitors to the area enjoy dining at Burdines for its relaxed vibe and delicious food, making it a favorite spot for both locals and tourists alike.

In addition to its dining offerings, Burdines Waterfront also features a lively tiki bar. This adds to the relaxed and tropical ambiance of the restaurant, providing patrons with a fun and casual atmosphere to enjoy refreshing drinks while taking in the scenic views of the waterfront. The tiki bar is a popular spot for visitors looking to unwind with a cold beverage in hand, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking a quintessential Florida Keys and Overseas Highway experience.

8. Tiki House

Location: 430 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040

Tiki House - the best tiki bars in the Florida Keys.

Nestled just a stone’s throw away from Key West’s Historic District and the serene waters of the coastline lies the enchanting oasis known as Tkiki House. A beacon of retro Polynesian charm, this hidden gem transports visitors to a bygone era of tropical indulgence and carefree living.

One of Tkiki House’s standout offerings is its Tiki cocktail classes, where enthusiasts can immerse themselves in the rich history of Tiki culture and master the art of crafting authentic cocktails. Led by seasoned mixologists, these classes offer a hands-on experience that promises to tantalize taste buds and ignite the imagination.

Situated along the Overseas Highway, Tkiki House stands as a testament to the enduring allure of Polynesian hospitality and the timeless appeal of island living. Whether you’re a seasoned traveler or a curious newcomer, a visit to Tkiki House is sure to leave a lasting impression, weaving memories of laughter, relaxation, and the undeniable magic of Key West’s tropical paradise.

9. Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort

Location: 80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036

Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort - in my opinion the best tiki bar in the Florida Keys.

The Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort is a delightful outdoor venue located in Islamorada, Florida. Situated within the resort’s scenic grounds, this bar offers guests a charming tropical atmosphere to enjoy cocktails and light bites. With its thatched roof and relaxed seating areas, the Tiki Bar provides a perfect setting for soaking up the sun or savoring sunset views over the water. Whether you’re unwinding after a day of exploration or simply looking to enjoy some drinks with friends, the Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort promises a laid-back and enjoyable experience in the Florida Keys.

In my opinion, the Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort stands out as one of the finest along the Overseas Highway. I highly recommend visiting, particularly in the evening or at night, for its exceptional views. It’s a prime spot to unwind and enjoy the scenic beauty of the Florida Keys. Whether you’re seeking a relaxing atmosphere to wind down after a day of exploration or looking for a vibrant nightlife experience, this Tiki Bar delivers on all fronts. The combination of its picturesque waterfront setting, delicious drinks, and inviting ambiance makes it a must-visit destination along the Overseas Highway

Don’t forget to check out the best clubs and bars in Key West here: The Nightlife of Key West: 8 TOP Bars, Clubs, and Entertainment Venues

👍 Find out more:

Overseas Highway Florida Keys Travel Guide - 101 best stops by Mark Watson

Explore the finest attractions along the Overseas Highway and Florida Keys with my travel guide, ‘Florida Keys Overseas Highway Travel Guide – 101 Best Stops,’ now available on Amazon. This comprehensive guide is your ultimate companion for those seeking adventure and wonder along THE OVERSEAS HIGHWAY & FLORIDA KEYS! Discover 101 amazing places with convenient ‘Scan QR and go’ functionality for easy navigation.


Pacific Coast - Mark Watson

Mark Watson is a California-based member of a Los Angeles motorcycle club and an avid traveler. He has completed seven full journeys along the iconic Pacific Coast Highway on his Harley-Davidson and is passionate about promoting this historic drive to others. Mark has also explored the Alaska Highway and Route 66, and has authored four bestselling travel guides on Amazon: “Route 66 Travel Guide – 202 Amazing Places,” “Alaska Highway Travel Guide – 202 Best Stops,”, “Pacific Coast Highway Travel Guide – 202 Best Stops”, and “Florida Keys Overseas Highway Travel Guide – 101 Best Stops.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *