Overseas Highway – The 12 BEST TOP Restaurants & Cafes – Florida Keys

Overseas Highway – The 12 BEST TOP Restaurants & Cafes Along the Florida Keys

Explore the culinary treasures lining the Overseas Highway with my exclusive guide to the 12 BEST TOP restaurants and cafes scattered across the enchanting Florida Keys. Immerse yourself in the flavors of this tropical paradise as we navigate through a curated selection of dining establishments, each offering a unique blend of local charm and exquisite cuisine. Whether you’re a seasoned local or a curious traveler, join me on a gastronomic journey that unveils the culinary secrets of this picturesque stretch.

What are the best restaurants along Overseas Highway? What are the best food spots on the Florida Keys? Where can I find great coffee on the way to Key West?

From oceanfront eateries to hidden gems, discover the essence of the Florida Keys through the lens of its vibrant and diverse food scene. Get ready to savor the tastes that make the Overseas Highway a culinary haven, where every bite tells a story of this captivating coastal destination. Let your appetite guide you as we present the top dining experiences that define the gastronomic landscape of the Florida Keys.

1. Caribbean Club

GPS: 25.14508, -80.39686
ADDRESS: 104080 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Caribbean Club - great restaurant on the overseas highway, on my top 12 food stops

The Caribbean Club is renowned as one of the best restaurants along the Overseas Highway and in the Florida Keys. Nestled in the heart of the picturesque Florida Keys, this establishment offers a delightful dining experience characterized by its unique Caribbean-inspired cuisine and vibrant atmosphere.

With its prime location along the Overseas Highway, the Caribbean Club stands out as a must-visit destination for those seeking an exceptional culinary adventure. The restaurant boasts a diverse menu featuring fresh seafood, tropical flavors, and expertly crafted dishes that capture the essence of Caribbean cuisine.

Guests can savor delectable seafood platters, flavorful island-inspired entrees, and indulge in a selection of refreshing beverages. The ambiance at the Caribbean Club is equally inviting, with a relaxed and tropical atmosphere that complements the culinary delights on offer.

2. The Fish House

GPS: 25.12428, -80.41295
ADDRESS: 102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

The Fish House - list of best restaurants and cafes along the scenic Overseas Highway (Florida Keys).

The Fish House in the Florida Keys stands out as a unique culinary haven, preserving a tradition of sourcing only the freshest seafood directly from local commercial fishermen. In an era where many establishments opt for pre-packaged options, The Fish House remains dedicated to procuring whole fish, ensuring an unparalleled freshness and connection to the vibrant marine life of the region.

What sets The Fish House apart is its commitment to supporting local fishermen and select vendors. This not only contributes to the sustainability of the seafood industry but also guarantees a traceable and authentic dining experience. The menu, therefore, becomes a testament to the daily catch, with a diverse array of dishes showcasing the bounty of the surrounding waters.

Situated along the Overseas Highway, The Fish House is not just a restaurant but a culinary landmark for those traveling through the Florida Keys. Its reputation as a great food stop is well-deserved, offering travelers a taste of the region’s maritime culture and culinary excellence. The laid-back atmosphere, adorned with nautical decor, welcomes guests to unwind and enjoy a meal while taking in the picturesque surroundings.

3. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen

GPS: 25.09203, -80.44396
ADDRESS: 99336 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

Mrs. Mac's Kitchen - stop at this top restaurant (Key Largo) Florida Keys, Overseas Highway.

Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, situated along the scenic Overseas Highway in the Florida Keys, has rightfully earned its place on the list of the best restaurants in the area. This beloved establishment has become a staple for locals and a must-visit for tourists, offering a unique and delightful dining experience that perfectly encapsulates the laid-back charm of the Keys.

Upon entering Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, guests are welcomed by a cozy and friendly atmosphere that immediately puts them at ease. The interior, adorned with nautical-themed decor, pays homage to the maritime heritage of the region, creating an inviting space that feels distinctly Floridian. The staff, known for their warm hospitality, adds a personal touch to the dining experience, ensuring that every visitor feels like a valued guest.

As you explore the Overseas Highway and traverse the breathtaking Florida Keys, be sure to include Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen on your itinerary. It’s not just a meal; it’s a culinary journey that captures the essence of this tropical paradise in every mouthwatering dish.

4. Coco Plum Place

GPS: 25.08093, -80.45472
ADDRESS: 98275 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037

What are the best restaurants/cafes along Overseas Highway? Coco Plum Place!

Coco Plum Place is a fantastic café that boasts a diverse selection of coffees and a delightful vegetarian menu. Nestled within, visitors can explore a charming small gift shop, adding to the overall experience. One of the highlights of this café is its beautiful outside seating area in the garden, providing a serene and picturesque ambiance.

For travelers along the Overseas Highway in the Florida Keys, Coco Plum Place is a must-stop destination. Whether you’re a coffee enthusiast, a fan of vegetarian delights, or simply looking to enjoy a peaceful moment surrounded by nature, this café offers a unique and enjoyable experience for all.

5. What The Fish? Rolls & More

GPS: 25.00229, -80.53159
ADDRESS: 90775 Old Hwy Unit #6, Tavernier, FL 33070

What The Fish? Rolls & More Absolutely great restaurant and definitely on my list of best restaurants on the Florida Keys.

ndulge your taste buds in a maritime feast at What The Fish Rolls & More, where the culinary journey is an ode to ocean-to-table excellence. This seafood haven takes pride in showcasing locally caught specialties, featuring seasonal favorites like succulent crab cakes and delectable lobster rolls. The menu boasts a diverse selection of seafood-infused buns and ready-to-eat entrées, promising a gastronomic adventure that mirrors the vibrant marine offerings of the Florida Keys.

Nestled along the Overseas Highway, What The Fish Rolls & More stands out as a culinary gem, beckoning travelers to savor the freshest catches the ocean has to offer. As you traverse the scenic Florida Keys, make sure to make this culinary hotspot a must-stop on your gastronomic journey. With its commitment to quality and a menu that captures the essence of the region’s rich seafood bounty, What The Fish Rolls & More has rightfully earned its place on my list of top restaurants in the Florida Keys. Prepare to be captivated by the flavors of the sea in a setting that epitomizes the essence of coastal dining excellence.

6. Marker 88

GPS: 24.97146, -80.55776
ADDRESS: 88000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036

Marker 88 - list of best restaurants and cafes on the Florida Keys.

Welcome to Marker 88, where the culinary journey is as extraordinary and incomparable as the breathtaking Keys themselves. Immerse yourself in an unparalleled dining experience amidst our scenic mangrove islands and tropical treasures, setting the stage for one of the Key’s most iconic culinary adventures.

Marker 88 isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a destination that beckons you to indulge in the best of the Keys’ cuisine. With an unwavering focus on quality, service, and the unique flavors of the region, Marker 88 has rightfully earned its place as a must-stop Overseas Highway and Florida Keys destination.

5. Bongo’s Botanical Beer Garden and Cafe

GPS: 24.76975, -80.94058
ADDRESS: 59300 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050

Bongo's Botanical Beer Garden and Cafe - stop and relax. Must food stop - great restaurant

Bongo’s Botanical Beer Garden and Cafe is a unique and vibrant establishment that seamlessly combines the pleasures of a traditional beer garden with the serenity and beauty of a botanical oasis. Upon entering Bongo’s Botanical Beer Garden and Cafe, visitors are greeted by an enchanting landscape adorned with a diverse array of lush, exotic plants and flowers. The establishment takes pride in its commitment to sustainability, featuring an eco-friendly design that blends seamlessly with the natural surroundings.

For those journeying along the Overseas Highway, Bongo’s Botanical Beer Garden and Cafe beckons as more than just a dining destination—it’s a sensory retreat, an immersion into the unique fusion of culinary artistry and natural beauty that defines the Florida Keys. Make it a point to pause your journey, indulge in the flavors, and savor the moments at Bongo’s—a culinary haven that captures the essence of this tropical paradise.

6. Sunset Grille & Raw Bar

GPS: 24.70642, -81.12383
ADDRESS: 7 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon, FL 33050

The best restaurants along the Overseas Highway (Florida Keys) - Sunset Grille & Raw Bar

Sunset Grille & Raw Bar stands as a culinary gem along the enchanting Overseas Highway, nestled amidst the breathtaking beauty of the Florida Keys. Renowned for its exquisite seafood, vibrant atmosphere, and unparalleled sunset views, this restaurant has rightfully earned its reputation as one of the finest dining establishments in the region.

Located on the Overseas Highway, Sunset Grille & Raw Bar offers patrons a unique dining experience, seamlessly blending delectable cuisine with the natural splendor of the Florida Keys. The restaurant boasts a charming and laid-back ambiance, inviting guests to unwind and savor the moment. With its open-air setting and tropical décor, diners are treated to a sensory journey that complements the stunning surroundings.

The menu at Sunset Grille & Raw Bar is a testament to the bountiful harvest of the sea. Fresh, locally sourced seafood takes center stage, prepared with a culinary finesse that showcases the flavors of the Keys. From succulent raw oysters to perfectly grilled fish, each dish is a celebration of the ocean’s bounty. The chefs at Sunset Grille are dedicated to delivering a gastronomic experience that leaves a lasting impression on every guest.

This is a great tiki bar, and if you would like to discover more tiki bars along the Overseas Highway and Florida Keys, check out my post: Top 9: Best Tiki Bars Florida Keys & Overseas Highway

7. No Name Pub

GPS: 24.69812, -81.35123
ADDRESS: 30813 Watson Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043

No Name Pub - The 10 Best Restaurants Near The Overseas Highway.

Nestled along the scenic Overseas Highway in the enchanting Florida Keys, the No Name Pub stands as a culinary gem, inviting travelers to embark on a gastronomic journey like no other. Renowned for its exceptional food and unparalleled service, this pub has consistently clinched top honors in the ZAGAT Survey’s Casual Dining category for numerous consecutive years.

Despite its discreet location on Big Pine Key, the No Name Pub has earned a reputation that precedes it. Those “in the know” attest that the drive to this hidden haunt is not just worthwhile; it’s an adventure in itself. The allure of unparalleled flavors, coupled with the rustic ambiance, beckons both locals and travelers alike.

Beyond the culinary delights, the No Name Pub extends its charm with an accompanying store where patrons can acquire souvenirs, ensuring that the memories forged within these walls linger long after the last bite. So, for those seeking an extraordinary dining escapade along the Overseas Highway and through the Florida Keys, the No Name Pub is a must-stop destination, promising a feast for the senses and an unforgettable culinary voyage.

8. Baby’s Coffee

GPS: 24.62861, -81.59284
ADDRESS: 3180 US Highway 1 MM 15, Key West, FL 33040

Baby’s Coffee - best cafes Overseas Higwhay

In 1991, Gary and Olga traded the hustle and bustle of the Big Apple for the serene charm of Key West, Florida, seeking the ideal spot to establish their coffee roasting haven. Their quest led them to a modest building on the uptown side of Duval Street, steeped in the rich history of the 1920s. This locale, once owned by a Cuban family who affectionately named it “Baby’s Place” after their youngest son, became the birthplace of Baby’s Coffee.

The building’s history unfolded as “Baby” Rodriguez, the namesake, grew up to run a lively cantina within its walls. Legend has it that Ernest Hemingway himself engaged in spirited games of chance with the locals, known as “conchs,” in this very space. Inspired by this captivating past, Gary and Olga embraced the name “Baby’s Coffee” when they opened their doors, paying homage to the building’s legacy.

Fast forward to today, and Baby’s Coffee has become a standout destination along the Overseas Highway, earning its place among the best cafes in the Florida Keys. The allure lies not just in the meticulously roasted coffee beans but also in the warm ambiance, the friendly faces, and the echoes of a bygone era. As travelers make their way along the scenic route, a stop at Baby’s Coffee isn’t merely a pitstop; it’s an immersion into the history and craftsmanship of coffee, seamlessly woven into the fabric of the Florida Keys experience.

9. Hogfish Bar & Grill

GPS: 24.56629, -81.73340
ADDRESS: 6810 Front St, Stock Island, FL 33040

Hogfish Bar & Grill - top restaurants on the Florida Keys - Overseas Highway

Nestled along the iconic Overseas Highway, Hogfish Bar & Grill stands out as a culinary gem, earning its well-deserved place among the top restaurants on your list. This beloved establishment offers more than just a meal; it delivers an unforgettable dining experience that captures the essence of the Florida Keys.

The menu at Hogfish Bar & Grill is a testament to the culinary artistry that defines the region. From their signature hogfish sandwich, a local favorite, to a diverse array of seafood dishes prepared with a creative touch, every bite reflects a passion for both flavor and authenticity. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff add an extra layer of warmth to the dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for locals and travelers alike.

As you traverse the Overseas Highway, a stop at Hogfish Bar & Grill isn’t merely about satisfying your hunger; it’s an opportunity to immerse yourself in the coastal charm and culinary delights that make the Florida Keys a unique destination. With its combination of exquisite dishes, picturesque views, and a relaxed vibe, Hogfish Bar & Grill undoubtedly earns its place as one of the best restaurants along this scenic route.

10. The Docks Restaurant + Raw Bar

GPS: 24.56500, -81.73345
ADDRESS: 6840 Front St, Key West, FL 33040

The Docks Restaurant + Raw Bar - Top restaurants Overseas Highway Florida Keys

Finally, rounding off my list of top restaurants and cafes along the Overseas Highway and Florida Keys is The Docks Restaurant + Raw Bar. This gem is a fantastic spot for seafood enthusiasts, offering a delectable selection of dishes that showcase the freshness of the ocean. One of their standout features is their exceptional oyster selection, providing a delightful experience for those craving the briny goodness of these ocean treasures.

The Docks Restaurant + Raw Bar truly stands out as a must-visit destination, where the combination of a picturesque setting and superb seafood creates an unforgettable dining experience.

👍 Find out more:

Overseas Highway Florida Keys Travel Guide - 101 best stops by Mark Watson

Explore the finest attractions along the Overseas Highway and Florida Keys with my travel guide, ‘Florida Keys Overseas Highway Travel Guide – 101 Best Stops,’ now available on Amazon. This comprehensive guide is your ultimate companion for those seeking adventure and wonder along THE OVERSEAS HIGHWAY & FLORIDA KEYS! Discover 101 amazing places with convenient ‘Scan QR and go’ functionality for easy navigation.


Pacific Coast - Mark Watson

Mark Watson is a California-based member of a Los Angeles motorcycle club and an avid traveler. He has completed seven full journeys along the iconic Pacific Coast Highway on his Harley-Davidson and is passionate about promoting this historic drive to others. Mark has also explored the Alaska Highway and Route 66, and has authored four bestselling travel guides on Amazon: “Route 66 Travel Guide – 202 Amazing Places,” “Alaska Highway Travel Guide – 202 Best Stops,”, “Pacific Coast Highway Travel Guide – 202 Best Stops”, and “Florida Keys Overseas Highway Travel Guide – 101 Best Stops.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *